College by college
| College | Bay Shore Senior High School | Central Islip Senior High School |
|---|---|---|
| Harvard | – | ✓ |
| Princeton | – | – |
| MIT | – | – |
| Yale | – | – |
| Stanford | – | – |
| Penn | – | – |
| Columbia | ✓ | – |
| Dartmouth | – | – |
| Brown | ✓ | ✓ |
| Cornell | – | ✓ |
| Duke | – | – |
| UChicago | – | – |
| UC Berkeley | – | – |
| UCLA | – | – |
| Georgia Tech | – | – |
| Swarthmore | – | – |
| Williams | ✓ | – |
| Amherst | – | – |
| Caltech | – | – |
| Vanderbilt | – | – |
| Johns Hopkins | ✓ | – |
| Northwestern | – | – |
| UT Austin | – | – |
| Pomona | – | – |
| Colleges on record | 4 of 24 | 3 of 24 |
| Ivy League | 2 of 8 | 3 of 8 |
✓: a published record (school list, profile, official data or varsity roster) shows alumni there. Students a year at each college, with sources, open on the map with a free sign-up.
Bay Shore Senior High School on the map Central Islip Senior High School on the map
Questions
Which is better for getting into top colleges, Bay Shore Senior High School or Central Islip Senior High School?
By published admits and enrollments, Bay Shore Senior High School reaches more (4 to 3) of the 24 top colleges Alumatlas tracks compared with Central Islip Senior High School. Bay Shore Senior High School: 4 colleges, 2 Ivy League; Central Islip Senior High School: 3 colleges, 3 Ivy League. Records count where alumni are on record, not how many students go each year; the yearly numbers open on the map with a free sign-up.
Which sends students to the Ivy League, Bay Shore Senior High School or Central Islip Senior High School?
Bay Shore Senior High School: Columbia and Brown. Central Islip Senior High School: Harvard, Brown and Cornell.

