Vetting › Review policy
Review policy.
How reviews of college consultants work here, in plain words. It applies to every review, every reply and every consultant alike.
Why reviews are here
Families pay college consultants a lot of money, often on trust. Reviews from families who worked with a consultant are the best way we know to tell the careful ones from the ones who overpromise. A review is the reviewer’s own account, in their own words. It is not our opinion of the consultant, and we do not add our own judgement to it. Reviews are the opinions of the families who wrote them, not Alumatlas.
Who can write a review, and what it may say
Write a review if you, your child or your family worked with the consultant. Say what happened and what it was like, in your own words: how they worked, what they charged and did for it, what went well and what did not, and whether you would recommend them.
- Stick to what you saw yourself. Say plainly when something is your opinion (“I felt rushed”) and when it is a fact you know.
- Give a star rating from 1 to 5 and, where the form asks for it, the year you worked together.
- Tick “I paid this consultant for their services” only if you did. It is never shown on its own; it lets the consultant confirm you as a client.
- Leave out students’ names, and anything else that would let a reader work out who you are.
- Before you send it, tick “This is my own experience and it’s true to the best of my knowledge.” A review cannot be sent without it.
You are responsible for what you write. Write only what you lived and believe to be true.
Reviews are published anonymously. Your name and email are never shown, and the consultant never learns them from us. We use your email only to check the review, and we may write to you about it.
What we remove
We read every review before it is published, and we remove a review or a reply that holds any of these:
- A false statement of fact presented as fact. “They charged us $9,000 and stopped answering in October” is a statement of fact; if it is not true, it goes. An opinion that is clearly yours can stay, even a harsh one.
- Personal data: names of students or family members, phone numbers, email or home addresses, school ID numbers, photos of people, or details that identify a student.
- Slurs, threats, harassment, sexual content, or a push to self-harm.
- A conflict of interest: a review of yourself or your own business, of your employer or a colleague, of a competitor, or of someone close to you.
- Paid or traded reviews: a review written for money, a discount, a gift or a favour, or one a consultant asked for in exchange for anything. A consultant may ask past clients to write an honest review; nothing more.
- Reviews that are not about the consultant’s services (for example, about a college’s decision), copied text, spam or advertising.
We can take down a review after it is published, with or without a dispute, when we find that it breaks this policy. A review taken down by mistake is put back as it was written.
Removing a review is about this policy, not about whether a review is good or bad for the consultant.
A thank-you from Alumatlas for a review
At times Alumatlas thanks families for writing a review with a month of Family Pass, our paid plan. When that offer is running, the review form says so. Its rules:
- Any review we publish earns it, whatever its rating. It never depends on the stars, on what the review says or on which consultant it is about.
- It comes from Alumatlas alone. A consultant cannot pay for it, add to it or offer anything of their own for a review: that is a traded review, and we remove those.
- One per person in 12 months. A review we do not publish earns nothing. If a review is taken down later, the pass already given is not taken back.
- A review whose writer received the pass says so on the review.
We do not edit reviews
Alumatlas does not edit a review. A review is shown in its writer’s words or not at all: when one is challenged, it either stays up or comes down.
Who wrote a review
We disclose who wrote a review only under a court order or other legal process. When that happens, we tell the reviewer first, unless the law forbids it. We never tell a consultant who wrote a review.
Which reviews count in the rating
Every published review is shown. Some count in the consultant’s rating and are listed first; the others are listed below them under “Other reviews”, and do not count. The rule is the same for every consultant:
A review counts when the account that wrote it is more than 7 days old, or when it is a verified client’s. A review written while signed out, or from an account less than 7 days old, counts only once it is a verified client’s, or once the account is 7 days old.
The page says the same over the other reviews: “Not counted in the rating: these were written while signed out or from an account less than 7 days old, and are not from a verified client, or we set them apart under the review policy.”
The rating is the average of the stars of the reviews that count, to one decimal, with how many reviews it is made of and a bar for each number of stars. Nothing is shown before there is a review to count. We can move a single review either way when the rule gets it wrong, for example a review we have reason to think is not genuine. That is the only exception, and it never depends on who pays whom.
The ratings in detail (honesty, responsiveness and the others), “would hire them again” and the tags are added up over the same reviews that count. A category shows its average only once 3 of those reviews rated it; until then it says “Not enough ratings yet”. “Was this review helpful?” votes, one per account, only let a reader put the most helpful reviews first; they never change the rating or which reviews count, and a consultant cannot vote on the reviews of their own page.
Verified client
“Verified client” on a review means two things agreed: the family ticked “I paid this consultant for their services” when they wrote it, and the consultant marked the review “This family was my client”. Neither side alone is enough. The badge reveals nothing else: no name, no dates, nothing about the student. Later, a review of a consultant booked and paid through this site will be verified the same way without anyone ticking anything.
Nobody can pay to change reviews
No one can pay us to remove a review, hide it, move it up or down, change its stars or change which reviews count. That includes consultants, families, advertisers and anyone else. Claiming a consultant page is free. Reviews are listed by the rule above, then newest first, for every consultant alike.
How consultants reply
A consultant who has claimed their page can post one public reply to each review. It appears under the review as “Response from” and the business’s name.
- A reply can be changed for 7 days after it is first posted, and deleted at any time. A reply deleted after those 7 days cannot be posted again.
- A reply is held to the same rules as a review and as comments on the site: no slurs or attacks, at most 1000 characters. Phone numbers and email addresses are taken out of every reply.
- A reply must never name, describe or guess at the family or the student who wrote the review. There is no way to write to a reviewer privately through the site, and a consultant must not try to find or contact one.
- Anyone can report a reply. We remove replies that break this policy; 3 reports hide a reply until we look at it.
How to dispute a review
A consultant who thinks a review breaks this policy presses “Dispute this review” on their page and says which part and why (at least 20 characters). Only we read it. Then we decide one of two things:
- Keep it: the review does not break the policy and stays as it is.
- Remove it: it breaks the policy and leaves the page.
We do not change a review’s words, and we do not ask the family to change them.
The review stays on the page while a dispute waits, unless it clearly breaks the policy, in which case we take it down at once. We tell the consultant what we decided by email. We never tell a consultant who wrote a review.
Pages we add ourselves
Alumatlas may list a college consulting business before anyone has reviewed it, using facts the business publishes on its own public website or in a state business registration.
- Such a page holds business facts only: the consultant’s name, the business name, the city or “online”, the website and the services offered. It never holds a home address, a phone number, a personal social media account, family details or a photo.
- We do not take these facts from social networks or from membership directories.
- A page we added says so, is marked “Unclaimed”, and shows no rating until a family reviews it.
- If the business is yours, you can claim the page for free: press “Claim this page for free” on it and show that you run the business. Claiming changes no review and no ranking.
- To correct a fact, claim the page and edit it, or press “Report this page” and choose “This page is wrong”.
- To ask us to remove the page, press “Report this page” and choose “This is my business: remove this page”. We read every request and decide it. If you want an answer, say in the note how to reach you.
A business cannot remove reviews by removing its page: reviews are kept or removed under this policy alone.
Nobody can promise an admission
No one on this site can guarantee admission to any college: not a consultant, not a family in a review, and not us. A review that describes a result tells one family’s story; it does not predict yours. Treat any promise of admission as a warning sign.
What this policy does not do
We read every review, but we cannot check every fact in it, and we do not take sides in a disagreement we cannot check. A review, a reply and a post are their writers’ words, not ours. We try to apply this policy the same way every time, and we will fix it when we get something wrong. If you think we did, write to us.
Questions and reports
Use the report links on the site, or write to collinhu1933@gmail.com. When this policy changes, this page changes, and the date at the foot of it with it.
Last changed 18 November 2026.